Back to the Lane

Advent begins November 29

The Almanac

The candy cane

A striped sugar cane. The story that it spells J for Jesus is a legend, and the real history is just as interesting.

A printed page of instructions headed Candy Canes, a recipe for boiling sugar and pulling and twisting it into red and white canes.
Candy canes, a recipe page from The Children’s Party Book, 1923. Public domain in the United States. Credits
When it is kept
All season
Where it fits in the year
All through the season

Hard candy sticks, the ancestors of the candy cane, are reported from the 1600s in Europe. They were white, not striped.1,2 The earliest known printed mention of candy canes is an 1866 short story called "Tom Luther’s Stockings".3 Red stripes show up on Christmas cards around 1900, but nobody knows who first added them.5,1 The hook may have started as a way to hang the candy on a tree. That is a guess, not a record.2,5

Robert McCormack began making candy canes for local children in Albany, Georgia, in 1919, and his company became Bobs Candies.3,6,7 Hand-bent canes broke often, so his brother-in-law, a Catholic priest named Gregory Keller, invented a bending machine in the 1950s that made canes in large numbers. Sources give 1952, 1957 and 1958 for the machine.3,7,1

A legend, not history

A story says a candymaker in Indiana shaped a J for Jesus, with white for purity and red stripes for his blood. It is traced to a 1996 children’s book and to forwarded emails from the mid-1990s. Candy sticks are older than the state of Indiana.5,1,3

A legend, not history

Another story says that in 1670 a choirmaster at Cologne Cathedral bent sugar sticks into shepherds’ crooks to keep children quiet at the Christmas Eve service. It is not found in print before the mid-1900s.3,5,2

Disputed

A German-born man, August Imgard, is credited with putting candy canes on his Christmas tree in Wooster, Ohio, in 1847. It is a local tradition with thin proof, and a 1938 news report describes cookies and nuts, not canes.4,1,5

Sources

  1. We don’t know the origins of the candy cane, Smithsonian Magazine
  2. The story of the candy cane, TIME
  3. Candy cane, Wikipedia
  4. August Imgard, Wikipedia
  5. The candy cane legend, TruthOrFiction
  6. Bobs Candies, Wikipedia
  7. Bobs Candies, New Georgia Encyclopedia